In my opinion, Haseena Moin has invested greatly in Sheena’s character,
perhaps even more than Zoya and Anji. Zoya
and Anji’s narratives emerge for the greater part out of their actions , that
sometimes turn out to be humorous. Sheena is not a humorous character. The
drama creates space for this character to actually sit down and contemplate
about certain issues regarding the
women’s question- marriage being the
most important. I perceive Sheena’s
narrative about marriage to be dynamic,
displaying external influences that shape and alter her views about what constitutes an
ideal marriage - love or material comfort? What does it mean to be happy in
married life? Does a single woman have a
future ? is it possible to break the conventional bonds and display female independence?
What role does ‘samjhota ‘ (compromise)
play? These are some of the questions that Sheena’s narrative struggles to
resolve.
In the beginning of ‘Dhoop Kinarey’ Sheena shows innocent optimism about marriage whereby
she entertains hopes of procuring Dr. Ahmer’s
love. Through her gestures like settling her hair before Ahmer’s arrival
and her expressions highlight her interest and emotions clearly. For Sheena the
idea of marrying her own colleague , Ahmer is not unethical as she says that
profession and personal life are not distinct realms rather they run
simultaneously and it is alright to
merge them through marriage. These
views about marriage undergo a radical
change when Ahmer does not reciprocate her love causing her to agree to marry
Nasir Jamal, despite being heartbroken.
Sheena resorts to compromise her true love
realizing that it is not always that a woman gets to have the man she desires. That is the truth about life and perhaps her
feelings were too far fetched as she defends her decision to Zoya “zindagi mein aisa hota hai”. In her
darkest moments then the audience
witnesses a changed view about her marriage narrative that is morbid, bitter
and displays a peculiar inevitability that constitute a woman’s existence. It is manifested in her lines “Aurat
akelee reh nahee saktee…usey mard ka
sahara lena parta hai… Muashira akelee aurat ko kaheen ka nahee chorta”. Sheena’s
take upon marriage is conventional and elucidates her fear of society’s
criticism.
Marriage is no more about love but about social security that only
a husband can provide. The theme of dominance surfaces as Sheena see’s her own
vulnerability” : “aurat khudmukhtar
honay ke bawaajood baybus hai . I felt that here Sheena is no different
than Charlotte in Pride and Prejudice
who also marries Mr. Collins in order to escape the perils of being a single
woman. Both Charlotte and Sheena see the practical aspects of marriage. Their
preferences linger towards material and social comforts and the idea of love in
marriage becomes erroneous, unreal, perhaps a myth. Characters like Sheena and Charlotte are products of
society, they are not inherently like this. Society and self experience
suggests to them that happiness is not about love , happiness is self created is what Sheena narrative then suggests: “ jab mujhey apney raastey k chiraag jab khud
jalaaney hain tau phir kaisee mayoosi”.
But Haseena
Moin refutes Sheena’s narrative by showing how a marriage devoid of love and
filled with deception has an adverse effect on the woman both psychologically
and physically. Sheena falls ill after
finding out about Nasir Jamals first marriage that paves way for her divorce. The
third phase of her transformation in marriage starts when she
No comments:
Post a Comment