Mr. Brocklehurst- Rigid, Pretentious and Hypocritical.
From the very first appearance Mr. Brocklehurst makes in the
novel starting from his encounter with Jane he begins to appear as a rigid, religious
show piece, which aims to represent religion only on the surface. He has no
regard for other views on religion that becomes apparent in his dismissal of
Jane's interest in reading the book of revelations or the Exodus and not the
psalms. His insistence on learning religious hymns, further signifies how Mr. Brocklehurst
himself is more bent on the more appealing or rather charming aspects of religion, as opposed to
its proper preaching.
Mr.Brocklehurst is seemingly more interested in keeping a
nursery as opposed to running a school that actually aims to inculcate true Christian
morality in its students. He refers to Jane as a 'chosen plant' of the nursery
in whom 'humility' must be 'cultivated'. Now I agree that religion may require
fostering of certain values in the people, but Mr. Brocklehursts use of such
language only shows how he is more rigid in what he does, something quite
similar to how a gardener would follow strict methodology in growing plants, in
order to make them appear as they are meant to be.
Mr. Brockehursts Christianity till this point in the novel
is only mildly questionable. However, once he returns to Lowood when Jane
starts her schooling there, it is then that his religiosity actually appears
more of an outward show to promote the school as a Christian breeding ground
and not an actual strive to create well rounded, moral Christians. Personally, being a curly haired girl I took
offence to the whole scene where he makes a big deal of how Julia's hair is
curly. He mentions how it is his 'mission to mortify in the girls the lusts of
the flesh' and that they are 'not to conform to nature' even though her hair
curl naturally. This again exhibits how he aims to create ornamental Christian
girls that must appear and look simple even if it means going out of the way to
create that look of simplicity. Whatever happened to the time wasted in
creating and unnatural look, something Mr. Brocklehurst apparently seems to be
against when he attacks the fact that girls waste time in making 'plaits that
vanity itself might have woven'. Here I was instantly reminded of how earlier
on he had mentioned that he found it to be a 'pleasing proof of his success'
when his daughter found the girls at
Lowood to be 'quiet and plain'. This only confirmed that I was not reading in
between the lines, but Mr. Brocklehurst himself was openly declaring his aim of representing
girls in a way that exhibit a certain Christian character.
This obsession with the external appearance of a Christian
is only confirmed when the whole dietary issue of the girls is raised. We learn that he
is partially responsible for the girls falling sick for he believes in a very strict meal plan for
the girls, even If it means that they are to eat 'burnt porridge' over the very
much available alternate of 'bread and cheese'. This he argues is to 'render
the girls hardy, patient and self denying'. This only confirms his taking the
idea of the proper Christian too far. He is adamant to hold on to his strict
schedules even if it means risking the lives of girls.
These consecutive incidents only confirm his rigidity,
pretentiousness and hypocrisy in how he treats religion. For him religion
seemingly plays the role of keeping his image afloat of someone who is very
responsible in running a school that acts as the foundation for Christian
upbringing.
No comments:
Post a Comment