One of the stark differences between Humsafar
and Dhoop Kinare is the manner in which class boundaries are dealt with and portrayed.
Humsafar is majorly focused on depicting class differences; the drama focuses on
Khirad’s lowly status since she is from Hyderabad and is poor, and sharply contrasts
Asher’s status through his family and his education from an elitist college.
Humsafar employs the use of clothing to differentiate the classes of the
characters, and moreover attaches certain values such as religiosity and virtue
with the lower middle class of society.
However, Dhoop Kinare is not shown to
propagate any one class, in fact the drama never engages in distinguishing the
classes of the characters. The character who is largely used to portray the
drama’s disengagement with the element of class is Fazeelat Bibi, and one of
the first instances of this disengagement comes in the first episode. The girls
are planning to go and see the house and Fazeelat catches them making the plan.
When she begins to interrogate them, it becomes evident that she speaks freely
and is not restricted by her position as the ‘aya’ of the family, and likewise
the girls respect her and do not reprimand her for being nosy or acting out of
her position in the house. When Fazeelat
says that “Is ghar ki koi baat humse chupi nai rehti”, it shows her importance
in the household. Such a personal relationship with the servants is not even imaginable
in Humsafar, where class is an extremely rigid element and shapes the relationships,
behaviors’ and attitudes of the characters.
In Dhoop Kinare the audience is shown how
Fazeelat is always worried about Zoya’s health and eating habits. Moreover, the
audience is also shown the casual relationship between Fazeelat and Baba (Zoya’s
father); he does not treat her in a manner that would imply that she is a
servant and works for him. With the death of Zoya’s mother, Fazeelat is given
the reigns of maternity and thus is granted dignity in her position. Dignity in
Dhoop Kinare is not achieved through wealth and class as in Humsafar, but
through age and stature as in the case of Fazeelat.
No comments:
Post a Comment